Making a difference for 50+ Years, Learn More.

Paychex Vs QuickBooks Payroll

Which Payroll Service is Best for Your Small Business?

Choosing the right payroll solution for your small business can have a significant impact on your business's efficiency and success. Paychex and QuickBooks Payroll are two prominent names in the payroll industry, both offering platforms dedicated to serving smaller businesses. But are either the best option for your company? See the detailed breakdown below on each service’s features, pricing, user experience, and integration capabilities to help determine the right fit.

Paychex vs QuickBooks Payroll

Paychex Overview

As a prominent player in the payroll services industry, Paychex provides businesses with robust payroll solutions. Their range of services for small businesses is available through Paychex Flex, a platform featuring payroll processing, tax compliance, and HR management functions. Paychex Flex enables users to automate payroll calculations, handle employee data, and generate precise paychecks. Users can add supplementary services like time and attendance tracking, employee benefits administration, and retirement plan management.

Key Features

  • Payroll processing
  • Tax compliance and reporting
  • HR management
  • Time and attendance tracking
  • Employee benefits administration
  • Retirement plan management
  • Employee self-service portal
  • Direct deposit and paperless pay options
  • Mobile payroll access
  • Customized reporting and analytics
  • Compliance support
  • Dedicated customer support
  • Scalable solutions for businesses
  • Integration with account and HR software system

Paychex Customer Support

Paychex offers customer support and service through a claimed dedicated team of knowledgeable experts to assist businesses with their inquiries and issues. Users receive support via phone, online, or email. The support team is available to guide users through the platform, troubleshoot technical problems, and provide clarification on intricate payroll topics. However, Paychex has not earned high remarks for their customer service, as reflected in the company’s rating on platforms like Trust Pilot.

Paychex Pricing

Paychex Flex comes with a choice of 3 different pricing tiers:

  • Essentials: $39 per month plus $5 per employee
  • Select: Custom pricing based on company needs
  • Pro: Custom pricing based on company needs

Paychex Pros & Cons

Robust tax compliance and reporting capabilities Limited customization options for certain features
Extensive HR and employee management solutions Some users may find the user interface slightly complex
Time and attendance tracking functionalities Additional fees for certain add-on services
Flexible employee benefits administration Inconsistent customer support
Retirement plan management options Some users report occasional technical glitches
Compliance support and regulatory updates Customers report frequent random errors
Integration with accounting and HR systems Some integration requires added work

QuickBooks Payroll Overview

QuickBooks Payroll is a comprehensive payroll management solution offered by Intuit, a well-known provider of accounting software. Designed for small and medium-sized businesses, QuickBooks Payroll claims to streamline and automate payroll processes like processing payroll, calculating taxes, generating paychecks, and handling payroll taxes directly within the QuickBooks accounting software. The platform offers features like accurate tax calculations, automatic payroll tax form generation, and integration with other QuickBooks modules for seamless financial management.

Key Features

  • Payroll processing
  • Automatic tax calculation
  • Payroll tax form preparation
  • Direct deposit
  • Employee self-service options
  • Automatic payroll tax filing
  • Integration with QuickBooks Accounting
  • Time tracking integration
  • Employee benefits administration functions
  • Reporting and analytics capabilities
  • Mobile access
  • Compliance updates insight

QuickBooks Payroll Customer Support

QuickBooks Payroll offers customer support to assist businesses with any questions or concerns, including navigating the software, resolving technical issues, or seeking guidance on complex payroll matters. Their dedicated customer support team is available through multiple channels, including phone, email, and online chat. Customer support is also available through a knowledge base, FAQs, and community forums where users are given resources and can connect with others online. Although the avenues to receive support from Quickbooks are more than leading competitors, Intuit’s poor customer reviews via Trust Pilot indicate the service is not equipped to handle the expanding needs of many small business owners as intended.

QuickBooks Pricing

QuickBooks Payroll is offered in 3 different subscription tiers:

  • Core: costs $45 per month and an additional $4 per employee per month. Adds unlimited payroll runs, automatic tax filing, payroll reports, and more.
  • Premium: costs $75 per month and an additional $8 per employee per month. Adds workers’ comp administration, same-day direct deposit, HR support center, and more.
  • Elite: costs $125 per month and an additional $10 per employee per month. Adds 24/7 product support, tax penalty protection, personal HR advisor, and more.

QuickBooks Payroll Pros & Cons

Automates payroll processing Higher costs of top features may be a dealbreaker to businesses on a tight budget
Support forum with FAQs and knowledge base No webinars or 24/7 live representatives on core or premium plans
Offers various payroll functions including direct deposit and paper checks Time tracking & PTO tracking premium feature only
Provides tax calculation and filing services with an understanding of compliance Personal HR advisor only offered with Elite Plan
Integration available with QuickBooks accounting software Limited customization options for certain payroll features
Can generate comprehensive payroll reports Customers report occasional server connection issues
Includes employee self-service features Lengthy support wait times

Paychex vs Quickbooks Payroll - Which is Better?

The answer may shock you—neither! While Paychex Flex and QuickBooks Payroll offer solutions for small businesses, neither provide the full integration and timely, personalized support required to best serve your small business. Enter Connect & Simplify.

Connect & Simplify, offered by The Benefit Companies, presents small businesses with a comprehensive HCM software solution that seamlessly integrates payroll, human resources, employee benefits, time and attendance, workers comp, and additional functionalities through a unified vendor platform. By adopting this solution, you can significantly cut wasted costs and enhance service quality to your employees, all while saving valuable time that would otherwise be spent managing the complexities of multiple vendors. Plus through our 5-star rated team of subject matter experts who take the time to understand your unique business needs and provide personalized 1-on-1 support, you’ll receive the assistance you need when you need it.

See the full Connect & Simplify vs Paychex comparison.

Full Connect & Simplify Features

Start Quote

Have a question? Contact us instead.